From the May 20 Oregonian....
"Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull" feels like an old romance re-kindled. The pleasure is still there, informed by nostalgia, but that pleasure is also ... complicated. Messier.
On balance, the first new "Indiana Jones" movie in 19 years is perfectly amusing. There are moments -- particularly in the film's first third -- that recapture the magic of the most beloved adventure series in movie history. Back in the hat and cracking the whip, Harrison Ford is brighter-eyed than he's been in a movie in a very long time. The paranormal mystery is fairly compelling, even if it loses some juice by swapping religious significance for sci-fi significance. There are funny moments, cool-looking villains and a couple of clever, easy-to-follow action set pieces that remind you just how good director Steven Spielberg can be at this sort of thing.
But there are also disappointments. Not "Phantom Menace"-level epic failures, mind you, but disappointments.
The film juggles way too many underdeveloped characters. There are silly, tension-undermining jokes involving monkeys and prairie dogs. There are too many shout-outs to previous films in the series. The script sets up big-deal relationships -- even bringing back Indy's one true love, Marion Ravenwood (Karen Allen) -- but does almost nothing with those relationships during its all-running, all-riddle-decoding final third.
Is "Crystal Skull" a flawless resurrection? No. Is it a lame reminder of our own mortality, revealing Spielberg to be an old duffer who's lost his touch? Absolutely not. Like every "Indiana Jones" sequel, it has its problems. It's a little cluttered, frankly, and the finale feels rote when it shouldn't. But it's also too diverting to call it a failure.
More thoughts after the jump.